Skip to main content

The Bullfinch


The Bullfinch
Donna Tartt
2014 Abacus

After two false starts, I am done with The Bullfinch, the 2014 Pulitzer Prize winner for fiction. The rather voluminous, in fact 864 pages in the paperback edition, book yielded to me when I was tuck with a digital disconnect for a period of four days. That did the trick. Though a good work, somehow, I felt, it called for an enforced freeze of some kind so that time will yield to it. Perhaps that summarises what I consider to be the problem with the book too. It is a good novel with sloughs of despondency and isles of enchantment, more isles and less the ponds of depression. The reader, like Bunyan's Christian, can progress in his pilgrimage after fighting off a series of temptations, which includes the not so charitable urge to put it down and move off! It was hard to agree with all the eulogies the blurb heaped on it, but equally painful not to, at times.

The narrative with its epic sweep revolves around the  life of Theodore Decker, who loses his mother in an explosion in a museum. The Fabritius painting 'The Gold  Finch' moves out with him as one of the dying persons assigns the work to him. It lands him not just with Hobie, the antique dealer and wood artist, but to a world of shabby charm and wild quiet. The Painting begins to move with him Theo becomes unable to either surrender the painting to the authorities or to get rid of it. As he gets transplanted to the home of his rich friend and classmate Andy Barbour, Theo's life takes off on the long road to drugs, deprivation and desolation. His runaway father returns and takes him off to Las Vegas and in the process he gets his next friend Boris. Boris has been though much and is averse to nothing. As Theo states towards the end of his story, Boris was never scared of anything. He stands with Theo to the end, though how far Boris has contributed to that end is curious.

Theo hits roadblocks whenever he seems to reach a satisfying end to his search for himself. This reluctant Kunstlerroman throws up repeated spanners to his works and Theo is left hanging with this philosophical inertia at the end even though he hits jackpot. He is not after money, he is after meanings. He is after a cause which will find meaning in the loss of his mother. His dabbling in carpentry, antique business and the passionate protection of the painting- all leaves him still in disarray. As always, the woman he is after, is not after him. The woman to whom he gets engaged is engaged with some one else. Between the magical Pippa and the rich, professional wife to be Kitsy, Theo is nowhere.

The Bull Finch has pace, though it fails to maintain it steadily. It does work like a page turner but the same as the urge to see the pages turn, the reader can occasionally feel that she is stuck with too long rumination on life and art, death and love. The tension between the buoyancy of art and drag of life runs through the book and these two cohabit dangerously. The reach of the story is quite panoramic: pathos and passion, crime and drugs, luxury and lack. There are characters memorably etched. Theo, Hobie, Mrs. Barbour, Boris, Pippa.. They stay alive and take their assured place among the many such fictional people who make up the readers' imagined realities. The book is built with a painting as its spine. But Dona Tartt has done enough to counterweight elements so that bird, an original, is made to proudly inhabit an ecosystem of fakes and farces.

The seemingly meta fictional glint of the work towards the end, where the writer tries to acknowledge the presence of the reader in her scheme of things, leaves the reader with a slightly odd feel. The story could have been given the flight which the bird was denied. Do we see a pattern because we have been staring long enough? Or do we see it because there is indeed a pattern?, as Theo wonders. It's Theo versus Boris. The Theo who will end up doing what he never wanted to and the Boris who will willingly do the same because that's the way it has got to be. The pseudo artist and the honest criminal, let us say. The painted bullfinch is home and dry at the end though the human quandary remains. 

Comments

  1. harsha4 October 2015 at 12:04

    Not sure if I am missing something here, but sir, isn't the novel called The Goldfinch, after the painting?

    I had plodded through the novel sometime last year and it left me a bit dazed- not that I didn't like it. I did enjoy it, but did also wish it were much shorter. :)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On Foregrounding the Backdrops

    On Foregrounding the Backdrops Much of my liking for large pictures has lot to do with the backdrops and the 'others' in the frames. By others I mean the also-rans, in a way! But this is more about the past when pictures were not so common, when not everything could be shot and framed, as we do now. Magazines with photos were a premium then and colour pics even harder to come by. Rather than the ones who were the focus, meant to be the focus, my eyes would involuntarily wander off to the rest of the things and people who have been caught by the camera. It is their looks, expressions, postures, feels, appearance, that my senses will work on. The man in the middle, or men, those on whom the story is supposed to zero in, will fade out and the backdrop will zoom in. Imagination tracking those to their illogical conclusions constituted my act of reading the pictures. It was such a delight as it helped one keep the trivial off and enjoy the core of the margins. When o...
13 comments
Read more

Can Politics Empathise?

  E. M. Forster wrote about the need for ‘tolerance’ and argued that the real force which can help rebuild the world after the World Wars will be not love or forgiveness, but 'tolerance'. Though I read that essay long back during student days, as it was ‘taught’ as part of curricular requirement, it was 'studied' and then abandoned, in a way. But still the argument of the essay kept coming back, as it does now. I didn't grasp quickly the inherent link between empathy and tolerance, but there sure is a reason why Forster showed up. There are many ways the two, tolerance and empathy, complement each other and the presence of the former can surely help build the other. Empathy is the capacity to know and experience how others feel, putting yourself in another's position. But is there something like political empathy? Why is it not there, generally speaking? I would like to explain political empathy as the capacity of one politica...
12 comments
Read more

The Profes'sorry'ate!

If what was reported in the social media sometime ago was true, an MLA once asked a Minister whether Professorship category existed in Colleges. The reply from the Education Minister was that it doesn't, even though, they say, the response was from the minister who designated himself as Professor! The tendency to brand oneself as professor among College faculty members is on the rise for while. Many of those who have even recently joined the educational service as faculty prefix a Prof. before their names. Or, that is what I feel when I go through some of the reports in the media regarding College activities. As a result almost all of the college faculty are entitled to be designated Professors that way! Some relate this with seniority. If you have been in service for a while, have been teaching long, then you can stick the label on you. Or you can allow others to stick it on you. It grows on you and you take a new feel about who you are! A Professor Babu enables you to be...
8 comments
Read more